NEW: First in Organization’s History – 11 Finger Lakes Cheese Alliance Farms in 1 Place!

Wrap It Up Gift Shop now offers an assortment of cheeses from the Finger Lakes Cheese Alliance where you’ll find: goat cheese infused with Rosemary Garlic, Red Hot Pepper, honey Garlic Blend, Mediterranean Herb, Cinnamon Cranberry, and Feta Goat Cheese.  You can also find Smoked Bacon Cheddar, 3-year Cheddar, Blueberry Jack, Garlic Herb Jack, Organic Extra Sharp Cheddar, Organic Dill Gouda, Organic Smoked Gouda, Organic Garlic Chives, Raw Milk Cheeses, Pizza jack, Raspberry Jack, Onion & Chai Jack, Jalapeno Jack and many more…

At Wrap it Up Gift Shop, they endeavor to showcase that talent by stocking shelves that are filled to the brim with hand-picked pieces from over 120 local artists.  Inventory is both eclectic and practical, suitable for any budget.

Owners Randy and Linda maintain relationships with each artist, ranging from a 10-year-old to a 77-year-old Trumansburg native, allowing them to keep the shop updated, while also taking custom orders on select pieces.

Items include (but not at all limited to) pottery, paintings, jewelry, clothing, beeswax candles, and New York State Maple Syrup and local honey, with new items arriving every week. You’re always welcome to see what’s new at “Wrap It Up!

While picking out those perfect pieces, stop by their cafe for a cuppa joe and one of their delicious cinnamon buns!

Posted in Cheese Trail, Dine LOCAL, LOCAL Stuff and Unique Gifts

Related Listings

Sunday Brunch

(607) 387-9761

214 East Main Street, Trumansburg, NY, United States

Open Daily (visit their website for hours)

The Falls Restaurant and Catering at the village edge of Trumansburg, a small town in Upstate NY, offers patrons a delicious, affordable eatery you can take the whole family! Regulars refer to it as T-burg’s living room, because the chatter is always friendly and the atmosphere relaxed. Read more…


624 West State Street, Ithaca, NY 14850

Store Hours: Mon-Fri 10am-7pm, Sat 9am-5pm

Thinking of buying a new bicycle? One of your first choices, and not necessarily an easy one, will be where to shop. It can be a challenge because there are a myriad of stores that carry two-wheelers, from specialty retailers, to giant department stores, to backyard garage operations. Read more…

15 Steps Gift Shop Ithaca


171 East State Street, Ithaca, NY, USA

10:00-6:00 Mon-Sat, Sun 11:00-5:00

With their roots planted firmly in the American Crafts Movement.  It was in the 70’s and 80’s, Ken made his living as a furniture maker and Bettsie made hers as a fiber and batik artist. Read more…

ZaZa's Cucina Italian Restaurant


622 Cascadilla Street, Ithaca, NY, USA

ZaZa’s Cucina offers traditional Italian cuisine with a contemporary flair in an upscale casual atmosphere.   Hospitality; it is what drives ZaZa’s Cucina to provide patrons the complete dining experience by delivering excellent food, attentive service, and fine wine in an elegantly designed space. Read more…

the Jewelbox Ithaca


301 Taughannock Boulevard, Ithaca, NY, USA

9:30-5:30 Mon-Sat

The Jewelbox showcases one-of-a-kind jewelry by local designer and goldsmith, Micky Roof. A true master of her medium, Micky’s masterpieces include intricately textured Wrinkle Rings, uniquely brilliant Twig Rings and bracelets, breathtaking Australian opal jewelry and one-of-a-kind custom pieces that reflect the equally one-of-a-kind personalities of her clients. Read more…


4367 East Covert Road, Interlaken, NY, USA

11:00-8:00 Thurs, Fri, Sat 10:00-3:00 Sun Brunch, 3:00-8:00 Dinner

The Crystal Lake Café at Americana Vineyards is the winery’s exciting adventure to give their customers a unique Finger Lakes Experience. They work everyday to create dishes made with fresh local products such as meats, cheeses, produce – even ice cream. Read more…

Write a review